Land Is Cheap. Building in the Keys Is Not.
In Monroe County (the Florida Keys), vacant land is selling for a fraction of what finished homes go for, especially brand-new ones. Over the past year, the typical vacant lot sold for $247,500. A new house built since 2020 sold for a median of $1,707,500. That gap tells you a lot about what it actually costs to turn dirt into a livable home down here.

THE BIG PICTURE RIGHT NOW
In the last 365 days, Monroe County saw about 3,050 land and single-family home records. Roughly half were active listings, a little under half had sold, and the rest were pending. The median price across everything was just under $1.2 million.
But the market is soft. There’s more than a year of inventory sitting on the market (about 13 months of supply). Homes are selling for roughly 5% below asking price on average, and with mortgage rates still around 7.3%, buyers can afford to be picky. This is especially true for higher-priced land and new construction.
LAND VS. NEW CONSTRUCTION: THE REAL DIFFERENCE
Here’s the clearest split:
- Vacant land: median list price $432,500, median sold price $247,500.
- New homes (built 2020 or later): median list price nearly $2.9 million, median sold price $1,707,500.
Land is selling for roughly 15% of what a new house sells for. Older homes sit in the middle, typically between $1.1 and $1.2million, while new construction commands a clear premium on both total price and price per square foot (970/sq ft for new builds versus much lower numbers on older stock and land).
WHAT THAT GAP SAYS ABOUT BUILDING COSTS
Take the median new-home sale price. You’re left with about $1.46 million of value that went into the house itself. Spread that across the county’s typical home size of 1,632 square feet and you get roughly $895 per square foot in implied construction cost.
New homes in the Keys are often larger than that average, so the true cost per square foot is probably a bit lower—but it’s still a big number. That helps explain why new construction sells for so much more than older houses or raw land. You’re not just paying for location; you’re paying for the high cost of building in a place with tight regulations, limited labor, and expensive materials and logistics.
HOW DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE KEYS LOOK
Not every island is the same:
- Key West: Higher prices ($1.3 million median sold) and older homes, but still relatively balanced inventory.
- Lower Matecumbe: Expensive ($2.35 million median) with more inventory sitting.
- Key Largo: More affordable ($890,000 median) and the highest supply of the group.
- Cudjoe Key: Tightest inventory and solid pricing.
- Marathon: Mid-range prices with elevated supply.
Land tends to be more plentiful (and slower to sell) in the Upper and Middle Keys. Waterfront and more established areas still command higher per-square-foot prices.
WHAT IT MEANS IF YOU’RE BUYING, SELLING, OR BUILDING
Right now the market favors buyers, especially if you’re looking at land or new construction. Sellers of older homes are seeing tighter gaps between asking and sold prices. Anyone thinking about developing land needs to underwrite carefully construction costs are high, inventory is elevated, rates are still elevated, and the Keys have their own regulatory hurdles.
Older homes (pre-2000) may offer more predictable pricing for people who just want to live there. Land and new construction require more caution.
Bottom line: Land in Monroe County has lagged well behind home values, particularly new construction. The difference between a $247,500 lot and a $1.7 million new house shows just how expensive it is to build in the Florida Keys right now.

ABOUT AUTHOR
Jaden Duxfield is a skilled Market Research Analyst at Sunland Group who brings a unique combination of strategic thinking and analytical expertise to the real estate industry. With a background in mechanical engineering and a degree from Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand, he offers a sharp understanding of the built environment. Jaden specializes in data-driven analysis to uncover emerging trends and guide investors and developers in making informed decisions. His proficiency in advanced statistics and Python programming is highlighted in his insightful blogs, where he transforms complex data into clear and actionable conclusions for industry professionals.
The information provided on this blog is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or real estate advice. While I strive to present accurate and up-to-date information, the content may not reflect the latest market conditions or legal developments. Any reliance you place on such information is strictly at your own risk. Sunland Group and I do not make any representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, reliability, or completeness of the information provided.
Before making any financial or investment decisions, you should consult with a qualified professional who can provide advice tailored to your individual circumstances. Sunland Group and I will not be held liable for any losses or damages arising from the use of this blog or its content.
Blog
Explore our property blog for in-depth insights into residential and commercial market trends, lifestyle inspiration, expert advice and global real estate updates.
SUNLAND MARKET RESEARCH
Lehigh Acres: Prime time to buy and build your dream home
SUNLAND MARKET RESEARCH
The Crown Jewel of South West Florida
SUNLAND MARKET RESEARCH
Miami’s Waterfront Gems: Single-Family Homes Riding High Amid Migration Madness
CORPORATE OFFICE
14 NE 1st Ave, Suite 305,
Miami FL 33132
PHONE NUMBER
(305) 209 1455